millershollow - Day 4 |
| Link:167645 Sat Jan 23 00:18:24 2010 |
| Time:2009-09-24 19:38:51 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2692061 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#3 #41 |
#1 | |
| You were too late, Dammit. opiomancer is the confirmed hunter (confirmed by no other Hunter coming forward yesterday). She was wrong about Let's try to keep clearer heads today, people. The most suspicious people to me at this point are | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 19:39:24 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2692317 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#14 #17 |
#2 | |
| Time:2009-09-24 19:39:53 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2692573 | Parent:#1 Siblings:#41 Children:(none) |
#3 | |
| Wrote that before the night phase ended. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 19:42:51 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2692829 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#7 |
#4 | |
| So the opiomancer the hunter killed So that one of: - The serial killer and wolves both targetted opiomancer. Joe, could you clarify who gets the kill in that case? - The bodyguard saved the victim of the serial killer. - The witch saved the victim of the serial killer. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 19:51:56 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2693341 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#6 |
#5 | |
Anyone up for some I've made | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 19:53:27 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2694109 | Parent:#5 Siblings:(none) Children:#8 |
#6 | |
| trying to fatten us up? | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 19:55:24 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2694365 | Parent:#4 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#7 | |
| the serial killer and the wolves both targeted opiomancer . . . poor hunter :) | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 19:55:36 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2694621 | Parent:#6 Siblings:(none) Children:#13 |
#8 | |
| NO, I just have a feeling we need a good meal. Plus one | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:00:16 GMT Author: Subject:wow, the carnage Link:167645#2695389 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#12 #29 #53 #61 |
#9 | |
| I have to say, and this may jinx me, but I do have to say, thank you The advice by the way was, "shut up and you'll live longer you big dork!" or words to that effect. :) So... Yeah, regarding voting. I think yesterday was pretty much a wash. I don't see any evidence pointing at anyone in particular at this point. Giant Laser is doing that leadership thing. So... Should we elect a Sheriff now? | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:01:21 GMT Author: Subject:Status Link:167645#2695901 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:(none) |
#10 | |
| LIVING: DEAD: Special roles remaining: Wolves (x3) Seer Witch Afflicted Bodyguard Martyr Ghost Serial Killer | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:01:43 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2696157 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#163 |
#11 | |
| wow.... five innocents in one day/night... we're not doing so hot here guys... the only wolf outed was killed by the cereal killer. for now, since he seems to want to know if he gets credit for the kill i'd vote which i have to take off for soon, dont take my sudden silence (i posted alot the past couple days) as anything suspicous | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:03:47 GMT Author: Subject:Re: wow, the carnage Link:167645#2696669 | Parent:#9 Siblings:#29 #53 #61 Children:(none) |
#12 | |
| Ha-HAHAHAHA! Leader? No, silly man. I have merely perfected Prof. Dr. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:17:13 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2698205 | Parent:#8 Siblings:(none) Children:#16 |
#13 | |
| QUACK! As you hear the familiar quack of the QUACK! | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:18:49 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2698461 | Parent:#2 Siblings:#17 Children:(none) |
#14 | |
| Cheater | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:24:33 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2698717 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#23 |
#15 | |
| If the Seer has at least one wolf and a couple confirmed people they may want to consider coming out so we can start saving them five times (and so the killer doesn't accidentally target them). Based on past games though the Seer likely spied on people who have already died. This is one of the reasons why it is not bad policy to target the quiet players for confirmation. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:24:35 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2698973 | Parent:#13 Siblings:(none) Children:#30 |
#16 | |
| I did not say the How is your family doing? Mwahahahaha. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:27:11 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2699229 | Parent:#2 Siblings:#14 Children:#19 |
#17 | |
| Are you trying to bring out the wolfs with the sexy booty icon? | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:29:02 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2699997 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#27 |
#18 | |
| GAME OFF Can we get a consenses to only use SFW icons please? GAME ON | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:29:30 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2700509 | Parent:#17 Siblings:(none) Children:#20 |
#19 | |
| I've been told it works. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:31:37 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2700765 | Parent:#19 Siblings:(none) Children:#25 |
#20 | |
| One of these days, if we survive the wolves, I need you to photo me. Everyone loves a natural redhead right? | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:37:28 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2701533 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#22 #24 #26 #38 #52 #59 |
#21 | |
| Here are my list of questions for the day: a) Why did the bodyguard not save our hunter? That was the most telegraphed kill in the world. I'm going to have to assume it was either doubt, inexperience, or possibly just bad luck on the timing. I'm really hoping it was the latter. b) c) Granting that, I'm not 100% sure we need to kill him, either. The fact that he did not claim to be a special to save himself makes me slightly less suspicious. And now there's actual information to go off of (somewhat) I'm going to start the day with a couple of new concerns. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:48:06 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2702045 | Parent:#21 Siblings:#24 #26 #38 #52 #59 Children:(none) |
#22 | |
| My suspicion of you is only a hunch. Looking back on past things you've said, nothing is incriminating. Just a tendency to accuse others. Which is par for this particular course. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:51:10 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2702557 | Parent:#15 Siblings:(none) Children:#47 |
#23 | |
| The SEER does not have 5 days of safety with the BODYGUARD-MARTYR-BODYGUARD-WITCH-BODYGUARD plan. On day 4, the WITCH can only save the SEER from the WOLVES. The SERIAL KILLER could, at that time, target the SEER. The SEER isn't as big a threat to the SERIAL KILLER as the HUNTER was, but that's still a risk. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:52:04 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2702813 | Parent:#21 Siblings:#22 #26 #38 #52 #59 Children:(none) |
#24 | |
| I'm sorry, I was at work this morning and only had time to post my musings from the morning, not to review all that had happened since 11pm Pacific last night. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:55:45 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2703325 | Parent:#20 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#25 | |
| I've been told by a number of natural redheads that one of their greatest regrets is not being able to prove it nearly often enough ;) | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:57:07 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2703581 | Parent:#21 Siblings:#22 #24 #38 #52 #59 Children:#31 #56 |
#26 | |
| actually, I was AFK when all the votes turned my direction. But, I wouldn't have argued. I'm a non special villager, and willing to die for the good of the team. The seer is probably good to come out tomorrow, unless the bodyguard, martyr, or serial killer dies, as we'll only have a max of about 5 turns left. Well, with players like | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 20:58:21 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2703837 | Parent:#18 Siblings:(none) Children:#32 |
#27 | |
| Fair enough, you asked nicely, and I'm sure those are snickerdoodle cookies I smell! | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 21:02:07 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2704093 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#34 |
#28 | |
| Oh my. I think I need time to think about all this. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 21:03:32 GMT Author: Subject:Re: wow, the carnage Link:167645#2704349 | Parent:#9 Siblings:#12 #53 #61 Children:#42 |
#29 | |
| This is the first time I've ever made it to day four in a Millers Hollow game! Well, we'll have to rectify that, won't we? Vote Just kidding. ;-) Unvote | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 21:07:47 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2706141 | Parent:#16 Siblings:(none) Children:#33 |
#30 | |
| Right, and there's a serial killer on the loose. *ponder* | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 21:11:41 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2707421 | Parent:#26 Siblings:#56 Children:#35 |
#31 | |
| This is either a very honest or very wolfy ploy. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 21:20:04 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2707933 | Parent:#27 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#32 | |
| Thank you very much. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 21:20:48 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2708189 | Parent:#30 Siblings:(none) Children:#40 |
#33 | |
| Those who accuse tend to get killed. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 21:20:49 GMT Author: Subject:heh Link:167645#2708445 | Parent:#28 Siblings:(none) Children:#39 |
#34 | |
| So, here we are, and you're the last player with a name that starts with "F" and has two syllables. Oh sure, Vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 21:25:01 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2708701 | Parent:#31 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#35 | |
| I just wish I could do something useful. Without any special powers, all I can do is hope someone else makes a mistake, and hope that I or someone else notices it. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 21:25:53 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2708957 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#43 |
#36 | |
| Seriously with so much gossip, accusations and mud slinging back and forth yesterday. I ask why would the serial killer not expect the wolves to go after opionmancer last night. Did he waste a kill or just not trust the wolves to do their job. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 22:12:14 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2709469 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:(none) |
#37 | |
| Yesterday was kind of a cluster-f*ck. I, too, don't get why the body guard didn't guard Opi. And, sadly, I don't know that we're any better of than Day 1 as far a leads go. Maybe look at who Opi mentioned as possibles based on snooping in someone's LJ...the wolves may have felt safe because none of the suspicious people were wolves? Just grasping at straws here... | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 22:19:36 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2709981 | Parent:#21 Siblings:#22 #24 #26 #52 #59 Children:#79 |
#38 | |
| About But in the spirit of voting for someone, I vote Also, please feel free to lynch me/eat me/kill me/etc. while I am gone. I signed up to fully play this game, and that should not stop game activities from going on. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 22:39:48 GMT Author: Subject:Re: heh Link:167645#2711517 | Parent:#34 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#39 | |
| but but but | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 22:40:59 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2711773 | Parent:#33 Siblings:(none) Children:#62 #68 |
#40 | |
| But it's got to be better than letting my family get eaten! Vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 22:46:45 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2712029 | Parent:#1 Siblings:#3 Children:(none) |
#41 | |
| I had no reasons whatsoever. About 30 minutes before the day's end, I got online to discover the whole we're-lover-villagers thing. At that point, three people had already voted for Gwydion. He was the only one we had even a chance of getting the lynch on to in the short time remaining, so I bandwagoned onto him. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 22:56:27 GMT Author: Subject:Re: wow, the carnage Link:167645#2712285 | Parent:#29 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#42 | |
| Weird, cuddlepuddle registered both the vote and unvote, but it still lists me as voting. To be ultra-safe: Unvote I Gotta be careful when you play around like that. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 22:59:43 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2712541 | Parent:#36 Siblings:(none) Children:#44 |
#43 | |
| Personally I think he wasted the kill. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 23:04:46 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2713053 | Parent:#43 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#44 | |
| It's not a waste, it's an overcaution. Neither were convinced that the other one could be relied on, so they both made sure it was done. Some mercy, considering the brutality. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 23:38:29 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2713821 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#46 |
#45 | |
| VOTE snoopyh24 Time to try another tact for me. Why are you not not a villager? | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 23:46:44 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2714333 | Parent:#45 Siblings:(none) Children:#50 |
#46 | |
| That's an interesting question, coupled with a convenient misspelling of my name. Remind me to thank I have no more proof than anyone else that I am a plain vanilla villager, not even a special worth protecting. If you feel that dogpiling on me will serve the good of the village, then there's nothing I can say or do to deter you from that course of action. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 23:47:15 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2714589 | Parent:#23 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#47 | |
| The Seer isn't a threat to the Killer at all. The Killer can be killed by the wolves and cannot win as long as they are alive. The Seer has no ability to affect or identify the Killer. The Killer could take out the Seer as you say, but if they do they have double chance per day of dying (lynched or eaten). I'm not sure the extra chaos generated would be worth being twice as likely to die. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 23:51:04 GMT Author: Subject:Lunch (dinner) time run down. Link:167645#2714845 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#49 #54 #76 #78 |
#48 | |
| My reason for gwydion was a hunch and the'd already been voted for. I was just trying to divert votes away from the possible (now confirmed) hunter and lovers. It was almost On a suspicious note, in the 11th hour, logophilia refused to switch their vote to gwydion even to save the hunter and lovers. It was the way they put it that struck me. I'd link to it, but I'm on my iPhone and I have no clue how to make that work. Anyways, that implies wolves, lovers, or strong OOC loyalties. I won't cast a vote just yet. I'll wait for more discussion. Anything to say, Logophilia? Side note, I'll be largely unreachable till after 9:30 or so. Not being quiet, just working. | |||
| Time:2009-09-24 23:54:59 GMT Author: Subject:Re: Lunch (dinner) time run down. Link:167645#2715101 | Parent:#48 Siblings:#54 #76 #78 Children:(none) |
#49 | |
| Gah. Forgot to say, "and we know they aren't lovers.". Stupid tiny keyboard making me rush things. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 01:10:39 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2717149 | Parent:#46 Siblings:(none) Children:#51 |
#50 | |
| Spelling gets me again. VOTE She's evil. Has been a wolf. And since we like to pick on defenseless villager's this game... Prolly that AND a wolf. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 01:41:35 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2717405 | Parent:#50 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#51 | |
| Not a wolf. And not necessarily evil - my random links just alleviate boredom. :) | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 02:09:49 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2717661 | Parent:#21 Siblings:#22 #24 #26 #38 #59 Children:(none) |
#52 | |
| Some interesting math. We're at 19 people left in the village. Ignoring the Afflicted, we have 9 people whose cards don't read Villager. 10 who do. We still have the witch's kill (and save), so we're in pretty good shape, especially if the seer has useful information, one way or another. Confirmed wolves may not be as useful as confirmed villagers, depending on the endgame. Those are facts, not conjectures. I think I'll end this with a Vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 02:42:22 GMT Author: Subject:Re: wow, the carnage Link:167645#2718173 | Parent:#9 Siblings:#12 #29 #61 Children:#57 |
#53 | |
| I 2nd the sheriff vote. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 02:54:24 GMT Author: Subject:Re: Lunch (dinner) time run down. Link:167645#2718429 | Parent:#48 Siblings:#49 #76 #78 Children:(none) |
#54 | |
| As I told him at the time, I found that fairly suspicious myself. Enough to vote for him? Not necessarily... but it does get me looking in his direction. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 02:56:12 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2718685 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:(none) |
#55 | |
| I'm somewhat suspicious of | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 03:31:16 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2718941 | Parent:#26 Siblings:#31 Children:(none) |
#56 | |
| since you dont plan to last the night, heres some advice that might help the rest of us. talk alot. spout every idea, theory, or suspicion. the more pressure everyone is under the bigger the mistakes. the bigger the mistakes the harder it is to worm out from under what you slip up on. the game is about studying behavior. the more data the better picture we get. the better the picture the worse the wolves chances. think of it this way, if we had had more info sooner we could have voted with more confidence and saved alot of lives. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 04:57:41 GMT Author: Subject:Re: wow, the carnage Link:167645#2719197 | Parent:#53 Siblings:(none) Children:#58 |
#57 | |
| i dont think that was a first vote. youd be first, if im not mistaken. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 05:00:26 GMT Author: Subject:Re: wow, the carnage Link:167645#2719453 | Parent:#57 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#58 | |
| crap. I guess it should be done before too many more villagers get killed. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 05:09:20 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2719709 | Parent:#21 Siblings:#22 #24 #26 #38 #52 Children:(none) |
#59 | |
| another option could be that the bodyguard was away from the computer and didnt know what was happening. did gwydion know the vote was swinging that close to him? that might be another case of being away from the computer. this game is alot more fun when your unemployed. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 05:33:12 GMT Author: Subject:... Link:167645#2719965 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#66 |
#60 | |
| I had a tirade planned. I'm no longer in the mood. Life intervined. As per my plan, VOTE I will not defend it. Agree or don't. Lynch me or don't. Eat me or don't. Tonight, I do not care. I shall make the decision weather or not to drop out or not tomorrow when I am sober. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 05:35:37 GMT Author: Subject:Re: wow, the carnage Link:167645#2720221 | Parent:#9 Siblings:#12 #29 #53 Children:(none) |
#61 | |
| too bad she didnt give for future games ill give this advice. if your lover wont shut up, smack them. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 05:41:43 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2720477 | Parent:#40 Siblings:#68 Children:(none) |
#62 | |
| it seems to me that this food theme is more than just flavor text. hahaha pun realized the moment i said it. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 06:19:44 GMT Author: Subject:hmm Link:167645#2720733 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#67 #81 |
#63 | |
| So I've agreed with him about needing a sheriff and I think he might have jumped onto something with his vote... So, in the spirit of not wasting my vote. Unvote vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 06:34:05 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2720989 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#65 |
#64 | |
Vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 07:26:57 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2721245 | Parent:#64 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#65 | |
| please note: I am going to sleep now. i will attempt to wake up before the deadline, but I'm not 100% sure it's gonna happen. Hopefully the game doesn't get drastically weird in the morning :D | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 07:43:04 GMT Author: Subject:Re: ... Link:167645#2721501 | Parent:#60 Siblings:(none) Children:#69 |
#66 | |
| are you suggesting that you're going to suicide? I'll wait to see if you do wolfie.... as it is I'm sticking to my guns with a)he's tricky enough to be furry or cruncy (cereal killer, i like to stick to two sylabbles) b) it sounds like he wants credit for the killing of ophimancer | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 08:11:23 GMT Author: Subject:Re: hmm Link:167645#2722013 | Parent:#63 Siblings:#81 Children:(none) |
#67 | |
| i still think | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 08:53:04 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2722269 | Parent:#40 Siblings:#62 Children:#71 |
#68 | |
| You vote has not been recorded. You must use a lowercase "vote name" for it to work, and the username must be exact. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 08:55:25 GMT Author: Subject:Re: ... Link:167645#2722525 | Parent:#66 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#69 | |
| Please re-read my post. I wasn't asking for credit, I was asking what happens when both killing groups target the same person. It is important that we understand if the witch or bodyguard are involved when one less kill happens overnight. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 08:58:45 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2722781 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#82 |
#70 | |
| I don't like voting when there is very little evidence, but that is something that this game is always short on. Also, I like it even less when two people vote against me. I am a villager. I don't even have hair in my armpits. Totally non-wolfy. But I'm not going to vote against others just because they voted against me. vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 09:07:04 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2723037 | Parent:#68 Siblings:(none) Children:#72 |
#71 | |
| Oh, I thought capitals were ok! Hmm, it's highlighted on To be sure: vote Because personally I think he is planning to eat us all. But then :/ | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 11:29:11 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2723293 | Parent:#71 Siblings:(none) Children:#73 |
#72 | |
| I probably was looking at an out-of-date feed from the cuddlepuddle summary. It lags by 30-45 min. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 13:31:42 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2723549 | Parent:#72 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#73 | |
| Ah, ok. Just wanted to make sure I understood it correctly. Thanks for watching out for me. :) | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 13:59:06 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2723805 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#104 |
#74 | |
| Well, I guess I'll vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 14:09:12 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2724061 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:(none) |
#75 | |
| VOTE | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 14:43:36 GMT Author: Subject:Re: Lunch (dinner) time run down. Link:167645#2724829 | Parent:#48 Siblings:#49 #54 #78 Children:(none) |
#76 | |
| Sure - i definitely have something to say :) As I stated - i don;t kill blindly hoping for luck to carry it through - I didn't see the current dogpile on Gwy as having a solid basis (no evidence to back it - just a sudden rush to lynch) - so I didn't add my vote that way. I DEFINITELY voted to save Ophi - and NOT to kill Syl as I thought the lover claim might be valid. I DEFINITLEY tried to save all the folks who died yesterday - check the votes :) | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 15:00:38 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2725085 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#80 #84 #85 |
#77 | |
| OK - have finally made my way back to the computer - to discover I'm the lynching target. Honestly, as I was unable to post till now, it doesn't surprise me, but it's disturbing to see my name on the rope with not even a THEORY why it's up there ... As per usual - I've been looking at the data, and I'm at a bit of a loss. I'm ... suprised the BGard didnt protect Oph, unless the BGard was convinced she was a wolf or the serial killer. I'm sad that the seer has not been able to gain enough info to come forward, but it's not that surprising - considering the high body count over the last several days and the still large number of folks remaining - it's possible all there scryings have died, and unlikely they have found a wolf. It might be too late considering how poorly late voting went last time, but I VOTE I'm pained to vote on my gut - but it seems that allthough you present information freely, it's not the most well thought out information, and you seem reticent to change your position once it's shown the data is poor. I beleieve I'm an asset to the town, please don't lynch me on a whim :) | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 15:04:19 GMT Author: Subject:Re: Lunch (dinner) time run down. Link:167645#2725341 | Parent:#48 Siblings:#49 #54 #76 Children:(none) |
#78 | |
| Oh - and the other reason I didn't vote Gwy at the 11th hour was that I could see that even before hungry's last vote - the WORST that would happen would have been a tie - which I figured would give folks a chance to say WHY they wanted Gwy killed off. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 15:22:50 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2725597 | Parent:#38 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#79 | |
| Gosh, thanks. This is the kind of help I DON'T need. vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 15:37:59 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2725853 | Parent:#77 Siblings:#84 #85 Children:(none) |
#80 | |
| I have lots to say in response to this, but I think that ad hominem attacks really get us nowhere. All my opinions are in fact well thought out, and whether or not I can communicate that is my failing, apparently. I'm not going to pile on because I agree you may be an asset to the village, but you've chosen poorly in targeting me. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 15:44:49 GMT Author: Subject:Re: hmm Link:167645#2726109 | Parent:#63 Siblings:#67 Children:#83 |
#81 | |
| This post here really strikes me the wrong way. It seems to be saying "Look, I'm going to pile on, but not because I've done any thought, but because someone else said so." Tomorrow, I expect to see "we lynched the x? Oh, but it was BEN's idea!" where x is anything from villager to seer. Just seems irresponsible in some ways, and not at all helpful to the village. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 15:53:09 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2726365 | Parent:#70 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#82 | |
| Why then did you vote for me ? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 15:55:30 GMT Author: Subject:Re: hmm Link:167645#2726621 | Parent:#81 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#83 | |
| Well, as it looks now, there will DEFINTELY be a lynched townsperson tomorrow as I am one ... | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:00:00 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2726877 | Parent:#77 Siblings:#80 #85 Children:#87 |
#84 | |
| What's the difference between voting on a "whim" and voting on a "hunch"? For me, you seemed suspicious with your really long arguments against a minor point that didn't really serve a purpose (in my eyes). It seemed to convolute things... That being said, I haven't voted yet, but will in the next half hour or so... | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:13:10 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2727133 | Parent:#77 Siblings:#80 #84 Children:#86 |
#85 | |
| Curious what the actual difference in voting on one's "gut" and voting on a "whim" is? I was suspicious of you yesterday because your arguments seemed to be more confusing than helpful, on some point of fact that really didn't matter. At least in my opinion... That being said, I haven't voted yet, but will soon. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:14:22 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2727389 | Parent:#85 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#86 | |
| erf...ignore this second one, I didn't see the first one posted, so thought my computer ate it... | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:15:31 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2727645 | Parent:#84 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#87 | |
| Well, a whim is something that takes you as amusing or just seems interesting. A hunch is when you have a feeling that something is true, but don't have enough eveidence to support it beyond doubt. Sorry I convoluted things (I think in the end that I did), but my problem was that folks were stating thing with certainty that didn't seem to be in any way certain to me. In the end, I thought that the opposition to my arguements had established that though NOT unassailable, thier arguements had enough merit to be used as a foundation fro voting, and I voted to that effect. I am feeling less than sure about my vote right now, and may withdraw it. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:17:49 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2727901 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#90 |
#88 | |
| I don't think | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:37:20 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2728157 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#91 #92 #93 #94 #107 #123 |
#89 | |
| OK - I'm gogin to lay out all the cards. I'm the WITCH. This declaration means that I will die tomorrow night (PROBABLY) via wolf attack if not lynched today. I will save my life tonight (if not lynched) so even if I'm not lynched, don't BGuard me (I doubt the serial killer will try to kill me off at this point). This is the only thing I think I can do to save the town a little bit of headache. Not sure if I should have used my save earlier - but then I'm new to the game. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:37:44 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2728413 | Parent:#88 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#90 | |
| I'm quite amused at the fact that I may be taking voting cues from someone I very nearly got voted off the village, but I'm considering backing the | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:42:45 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2728669 | Parent:#89 Siblings:#92 #93 #94 #107 #123 Children:#95 #100 #120 |
#91 | |
| I certainly hope you are the witch, else you'll be poisoned tonight. unvote Might as well join the dogpile. vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:42:54 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2728925 | Parent:#89 Siblings:#91 #93 #94 #107 #123 Children:#98 #99 |
#92 | |
| Nope, nothing thus far has called for the use of your save. I wish you had waited approximately 2 more minutes before the reveal, but such is life :P You have two more nights to live, as you've said. Possibly 3, depending on how much fun we feel like having with psychology. There are now two options: 1) Bodyguard watches you tonight. 2) They don't. If 1), then that branch leads to two other options a) The wolves expect it, and thus try and kill someone else, or b) they try and kill you anyways. We can do some fun shell game stuff, depending on what we think people are likely to do. With good timing, you could live for a good long while. Bodyguard, please pay attention, as it ultimately is your call how this mess goes down. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:43:45 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2729181 | Parent:#89 Siblings:#91 #92 #94 #107 #123 Children:(none) |
#93 | |
| Also, you are one of the sure ways we can kill the serial killer, so I strongly urge the bodyguard to protect you. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:44:56 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2729437 | Parent:#89 Siblings:#91 #92 #93 #107 #123 Children:#96 #101 #147 |
#94 | |
| ooooooooook. well, uh... vote Also, I've never been a Witch, so I don't know, but... can you use your potion to save yourself? And does it save you from both? I mean, you want to be very clear on how it works, if you're trusting your life to it. Also also, do we have anyone else for the bodyguard to protect? Doesn't it make sense for them to protect you against both targets, and save your potion? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:45:26 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2729693 | Parent:#91 Siblings:#100 #120 Children:#140 |
#95 | |
| Ugh... all this use of the word dogpile is really irking me :P Bandwagon is generally used for the tide of votes, dogpile is the implication that there's a canine element involved... As of now, I'm running more and more in circles about certain people. Laser's activity today has been much different than his involvement in previous days. Not saying it's a bad thing, just noting it. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:46:38 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2729949 | Parent:#94 Siblings:#101 #147 Children:#97 |
#96 | |
| The potion doesn't work against the serial killer. The bodyguard does. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:48:22 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2730205 | Parent:#96 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#97 | |
| Ok, good to know. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:50:08 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2730461 | Parent:#92 Siblings:#99 Children:(none) |
#98 | |
| Oh, the other thing is that you may get more life than that, if someone more important comes forward. We can get you to approximately 7 days of life, if you can get tacked on to the seer combo. We might want to use the seer next turn, simply to get the information out, and add some more life to our witch. Not saying it's definite, but if the seer has useful information, it'd be exceptional, assuming they live out the night. Or, as is always the case, I could be running smokescreen for myself, and you cannot drink the wine in front of me. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:50:21 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2730717 | Parent:#92 Siblings:#98 Children:#102 #105 |
#99 | |
| I REALY wanted to wait as long as possible, but apparently I jumped the gun :( Bodyguard should NOT protect me tonight - if the wolves attack i'll know it and can save myself. If the serial killer decides to kill me ... well, then that's unfortunate, and NOT in Killer's interest either. The wolves may NOT attack me tonight, as they would waste thier attack, in which case I'll still hold onto my save for the seer. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:51:42 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2730973 | Parent:#91 Siblings:#95 #120 Children:(none) |
#100 | |
| We have enough time and active commenters that we could probably discuss this and pick someone to vote for rather than dogpile... but I don't know that any of us have any clues to go on, so I'm not sure we could find a better target. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:52:51 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2731229 | Parent:#94 Siblings:#96 #147 Children:#103 |
#101 | |
| I can save from the wolves, not the killer. The bodygaurd is ACTUALLY better off protecting someone else - the chances are good that even a blind protect will save a villager, and will lessen the threat of the afflicted by a wee bit. If the wolves attack me I WILL use my potion to save myself - this would be a waste if the BGuard protects me as well. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:52:59 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2731485 | Parent:#99 Siblings:#105 Children:(none) |
#102 | |
| But why wouldn't the bodyguard protect you? You're our only confirmed villager. There's no one else for them to protect. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:54:38 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2731741 | Parent:#101 Siblings:(none) Children:#113 #116 |
#103 | |
| I disagree. The ability to save your potion seems more important to me than the chance of protecting a villager. But then, it's not really up to us, is it? :P Also, I thought that if the bodyguard protects you, you never get attacked, so you never use the potion. Could be wrong though. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:56:42 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2731997 | Parent:#74 Siblings:(none) Children:#106 |
#104 | |
| vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:57:19 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2732253 | Parent:#99 Siblings:#102 Children:#108 |
#105 | |
| Nah, you did just fine. Any longer, and people may not have had time to react. It was the fact that I was in the middle of posting to try and save you :p That was it. It is my opinion that it IS in the serial killer's interest to kill you, and therefore worth the bodyguard paying attention to you. Bodyguard, you get to make the call. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:58:42 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2732509 | Parent:#104 Siblings:(none) Children:#110 |
#106 | |
| btw, we ruled against edits. not really a big deal when all you do is bold your text, but JSYK. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:59:07 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2732765 | Parent:#89 Siblings:#91 #92 #93 #94 #123 Children:#112 |
#107 | |
| Well, crap. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 16:59:30 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2733021 | Parent:#105 Siblings:(none) Children:#109 |
#108 | |
| Why should the Serial Killer kill me ? My poison is a sure-shot, true, but if we are sure enough who the SKiller is, why wouldn't we lynch them ? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:01:17 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2733277 | Parent:#108 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#109 | |
| Also, the logic of "the wolves won't eat me, and waste their kill" is flawed. They know you have that potion. It's going to get used sometime, and they're unlikely to be deterred by its brandishing :P The Serial Killer would kill you, because you are good for the village. He wants to be the only one alive. He'll kill you, now or later, it's mostly the same to him. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:02:23 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2733533 | Parent:#106 Siblings:(none) Children:#111 |
#110 | |
| Yeah, I only did that to get the bolding right. I wouldn't edit for content. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:03:04 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2733789 | Parent:#110 Siblings:(none) Children:#114 #115 |
#111 | |
| Is there a reason you're voting | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:03:53 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2734045 | Parent:#107 Siblings:(none) Children:#117 |
#112 | |
| Sorry ... | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:06:13 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2734301 | Parent:#103 Siblings:#116 Children:(none) |
#113 | |
| I agree with H&H. If the bodyguard saves you, you don't even get the chance for your potion to be used, so it's not wasted. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:08:06 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2734557 | Parent:#111 Siblings:#115 Children:#118 #122 |
#114 | |
| Yes. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:08:07 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2734813 | Parent:#111 Siblings:#114 Children:(none) |
#115 | |
| I'm curious as well. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:08:13 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2735069 | Parent:#103 Siblings:#113 Children:#125 |
#116 | |
| .... damn - can't find anything to prove or disprove this. OK - my current take is that we ask Joe for clarification on this point before BGuard does his/her save. IF the BGuard's save causes me NOT to waste my potion, then BGuard feel free to SAVE me. IF I save and BGuard saves means to potion is lost, then the BGuard should save someone else, as I will use my potion to save myself OR tonight's villager target and thus prove my witchiness as well as one other person's villagrness. Thoughts ? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:08:20 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2735325 | Parent:#112 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#117 | |
| I was just lamenting the loss of the only hunch I had. :P | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:09:30 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2735581 | Parent:#114 Siblings:#122 Children:#121 |
#118 | |
| Given your brevity, I take it you don't want to share with the rest of us... | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:09:34 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2735837 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #127 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:(none) |
#119 | |
| vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:10:40 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2736093 | Parent:#91 Siblings:#95 #100 Children:(none) |
#120 | |
| unvote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:11:01 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2736349 | Parent:#118 Siblings:(none) Children:#129 |
#121 | |
| Can't talk. Eating. Mouth is full. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:11:06 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2736605 | Parent:#114 Siblings:#118 Children:#124 #126 #135 |
#122 | |
| Could you elaborate somewhat? I'm happy to change my vote, as I have no reasons to vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:13:03 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2736861 | Parent:#89 Siblings:#91 #92 #93 #94 #107 Children:(none) |
#123 | |
| if you are the witch, you should let the body guard guard you, and only use the potion if still attacked. don't plan it out, so the wolves have to keep trying to attack you to get you to use the potion. If they know you're going to use it today, they can just attack you, you use it, and then it's no good to anyone. every day that we can keep someone alive ups our chances. The serial killer shouldn't want you to go out until you've used the poison, I would think, but it depends on how they're playing it, but just in case, if he knows, he can just attack you when he knows you're bodyguardless. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:13:23 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2737117 | Parent:#122 Siblings:#126 #135 Children:#128 |
#124 | |
| Same here. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:23:28 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2737629 | Parent:#116 Siblings:(none) Children:#130 |
#125 | |
| The bodyguard save happens before the witch healing potion. ie if the bodyguard saves the victim, there is no victim for the witch to heal. if the martyr saves the victim, well there is obviously a victim for the witch to save, it's just not the original one. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:24:47 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2737885 | Parent:#122 Siblings:#124 #135 Children:#131 |
#126 | |
| and just a heads up, you just voted :) | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:25:30 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2738141 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #155 #157 #159 #164 Children:#132 |
#127 | |
| Well since Now would be a great time for the Seer to speak up. Seer, you out there??? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:25:33 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2738397 | Parent:#124 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#128 | |
| I'd like to know the logic behind this - I'm fine voting for someone other than dragon, but I don't vote blindly. In fact unvote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:25:45 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2738653 | Parent:#121 Siblings:(none) Children:#137 |
#129 | |
| sounds like you may be the seer and don't want to out yourself yet... | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:27:50 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2738909 | Parent:#125 Siblings:(none) Children:#133 |
#130 | |
| OK, so then we hope for BGuard to actually, Y'know, GUARD me ... if not i'll use my potion. NOW - thoughts - now that I'm outed, should i use my potion to save someone ELSE the wolves target tonight, thus giving us 2 known villagers ? Or save it ? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:28:01 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2739165 | Parent:#126 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#131 | |
| oh shit, hahahaha, thanks for the heads up. vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:29:22 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2739421 | Parent:#127 Siblings:(none) Children:#134 #149 |
#132 | |
| DO NOT OUT SEER, unless you have at least one known wolf at this point, it's useless. Don't you think Lamb ? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:29:55 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2739677 | Parent:#130 Siblings:(none) Children:#138 |
#133 | |
| Two known villagers? Who said anything about two known villagers? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:30:54 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2739933 | Parent:#132 Siblings:#149 Children:(none) |
#134 | |
| well obviously. unless the seer knows a wolf or the killers. I meant speak up if you know something. (i thought that was an obvious statement) | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:31:42 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2740189 | Parent:#122 Siblings:#124 #126 Children:#136 |
#135 | |
| maybe he's the seer and doesn't want to out himself | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:32:37 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2740445 | Parent:#135 Siblings:(none) Children:#142 |
#136 | |
| If he is the Seer, and | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:34:28 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2740701 | Parent:#129 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#137 | |
| I HOPE not ... if the seer has positively IDed a wolf at this point, then he/ she should come out so we can protect him/ her while we search for the remaining wolves. We can still protect with WITCH - BGUARD and Martye for serveral rounds. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:36:58 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2740957 | Parent:#133 Siblings:(none) Children:#139 #145 |
#138 | |
| If bguard protects me, and I protect the victim, I can reveal the victim, who is a villager, unless the wolves can attack one of thier own ??? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:38:38 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2741213 | Parent:#138 Siblings:#145 Children:#141 #144 #151 |
#139 | |
| Not only can they, but they've actually done it before. I believe that one is the | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:40:13 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2741469 | Parent:#95 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#140 | |
| Auugh! I forgot about that. I certainly meant "bandwagon". | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:40:31 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2741725 | Parent:#139 Siblings:#144 #151 Children:#143 #153 |
#141 | |
| well ... wow. Still, with only 3 wolves left, that seems ... unlikely ? | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:41:18 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2741981 | Parent:#136 Siblings:(none) Children:#146 |
#142 | |
| I at least had some reasons for voting that way... whereas i have no reason at all for | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:43:31 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2742237 | Parent:#141 Siblings:#153 Children:(none) |
#143 | |
| Why? They'd be a confirmed villager, unless the Seer checked them. They'd be nearly free of suspicion until it was too late for us to do anything. And if they knew you were planning to save the villager attacked tonight, that would make it a very tempting gamble. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:43:48 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2742493 | Parent:#139 Siblings:#141 #151 Children:#148 |
#144 | |
| Yup. You have in fact correctly labeled the | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:44:01 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2742749 | Parent:#138 Siblings:#139 Children:#150 |
#145 | |
| if the wolves eat one of thier own won't they show up as dead wolf in the morning?> | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:44:18 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2743005 | Parent:#142 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#146 | |
| I'd really like to hear some reasoning for either candidate, or i'll continue | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:46:27 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2743261 | Parent:#94 Siblings:#96 #101 Children:#152 |
#147 | |
| Well, you are one of the deciding votes. Right now it seems to be | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:47:34 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2743517 | Parent:#144 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#148 | |
| Damn ... OK - I will save my save for a better shot then .... Just trying to be as usefull as possible now that I've outed myself. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:48:25 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2743773 | Parent:#132 Siblings:#134 Children:#154 #156 |
#149 | |
| I find it suspicious that she is trying to get the SEER to come out so early. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:48:29 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2744029 | Parent:#145 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#150 | |
| unless the "victim" were saved by a special. exactly what i was just proposing .... | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:48:36 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2744285 | Parent:#139 Siblings:#141 #144 Children:(none) |
#151 | |
| i thought it was just joe's gambit | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:49:51 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2744541 | Parent:#147 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#152 | |
| Ehhh, the whole thing is a swing either way, whether onto | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:50:02 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2744797 | Parent:#141 Siblings:#143 Children:(none) |
#153 | |
| who's got big balls! I've got big balls! and for reference, there were only two wolves left the time I pulled the | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:50:46 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2745053 | Parent:#149 Siblings:#156 Children:(none) |
#154 | |
| Same. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:52:06 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2745309 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #157 #159 #164 Children:#158 #161 |
#155 | |
| UNVOTE VOTE | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:55:13 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2745565 | Parent:#149 Siblings:#154 Children:#162 |
#156 | |
| I'll admit - that's why I challenged Lamb, but .... still, could just be an overhasty posting. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:55:37 GMT Author: Subject:well damn Link:167645#2745821 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #159 #164 Children:#160 |
#157 | |
| okay, unvote vote | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:57:08 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2746077 | Parent:#155 Siblings:#161 Children:(none) |
#158 | |
| Wow - last minute bid to tie the vote eh ? No that I object mind you, but I'd like to hear why after the cut and when we have to vote for tie breaker :) | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:58:11 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2746333 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #164 Children:(none) |
#159 | |
| I'm sorry to have to do this now. I am the SEER. Do not lynch me. Protectors, I'll need you tonight. I do not have useful help to report. My DEVICE, my ... SEEING DEVICE ... revealed the following: Day 1 - Day 2 - Day 3 - I hope to live a few more days, but I cannot do that if you bandwagon on me now. Please change your votes. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:58:32 GMT Author: Subject:Re: well damn Link:167645#2746589 | Parent:#157 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#160 | |
| I am the SEER. See my post. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:58:45 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2746845 | Parent:#155 Siblings:#158 Children:(none) |
#161 | |
| I am the SEER. See my post. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:58:49 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2747101 | Parent:#156 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#162 | |
| I'm not the seer. I was just hoping the seer would step up if something was known. My vote for | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 17:59:12 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2747357 | Parent:#11 Siblings:(none) Children:(none) |
#163 | |
| I am the SEER. See my post. | |||
| Time:2009-09-25 18:01:10 GMT Author: Subject:(none) Link:167645#2747869 | Parent:(none) Siblings:#1 #2 #4 #5 #9 #10 #11 #15 #18 #21 #28 #36 #37 #45 #48 #55 #60 #63 #64 #70 #74 #75 #77 #88 #89 #119 #127 #155 #157 #159 Children:(none) |
#164 | |
| POST CLOSED . . . waiting ten plus minutes to tally votes . . . then announcing the results . . . if a tie happens we go into sudden death two hour run off . . . | |||
| vote | 2009-09-24 20:01:43 GMT | #11 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-24 21:03:32 GMT | #29 | |||
| unvote | 2009-09-24 21:03:32 GMT | #29 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-24 21:20:49 GMT | #34 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-24 22:19:36 GMT | #38 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-24 22:40:59 GMT | #40 | |||
| unvote | 2009-09-24 22:56:27 GMT | #42 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-24 22:56:27 GMT | #42 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 01:10:39 GMT | #50 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 02:09:49 GMT | #52 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 05:33:12 GMT | #60 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 06:19:44 GMT | #63 | |||
| unvote | 2009-09-25 06:19:44 GMT | #63 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 06:19:44 GMT | #63 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 06:34:05 GMT | #64 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 08:58:45 GMT | #70 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 09:07:04 GMT | #71 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 13:59:06 GMT | #74 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 14:09:12 GMT | #75 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 15:00:38 GMT | #77 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 15:22:50 GMT | #79 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 16:17:49 GMT | #88 | |||
| unvote | 2009-09-25 16:42:45 GMT | #91 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 16:42:45 GMT | #91 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 16:44:56 GMT | #94 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 16:56:42 GMT | #104 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 17:09:34 GMT | #119 | |||
| unvote | 2009-09-25 17:10:40 GMT | #120 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 17:10:40 GMT | #120 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 17:11:06 GMT | #122 | |||
| unvote | 2009-09-25 17:25:33 GMT | #128 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 17:25:33 GMT | #128 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 17:28:01 GMT | #131 | |||
| unvote | 2009-09-25 17:52:06 GMT | #155 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 17:52:06 GMT | #155 | |||
| unvote | 2009-09-25 17:55:37 GMT | #157 | |||
| vote | 2009-09-25 17:55:37 GMT | #157 |
| 6 against | : | ||
| 5 against | : | ||
| 3 against | : | ||
| 1 against | : | ||
| 1 against | : | ||
| 1 against | : | ||
| Posted but no vote | : | ||